I run a directory with 4,323 AI tool listings. Every row has exactly one pricing label: free, freemium, or paid. On paper the split looks healthy:
free: 2,198 (50.8%)
freemium: 1,425 (33.0%)
paid: 700 (16.2%)
For a site whose main feature is "filter by price", those are the numbers I care about most. Then I asked a different question: how many of these rows has anyone actually confirmed?
Each listing can carry a verified badge, which means the vendor went through a claim flow and said "yes, this is us". 614 of 4,323 do. That is 14.2%. The split by pricing tier is where it gets interesting:
Label Listings Verified Verified rate
free 2,198 261 11.9%
freemium 1,425 225 15.8%
paid 700 128 18.3%
Free listings are the least verified segment, paid listings the most. I am not going to pretend this is causal. This directory has produced 4 outbound clicks in total, so nothing here is statistically impressive.…