Kiss fans got a familiar song with a different voice when Smashes, Thrashes & Hits arrived on Nov. 15, 1988. Instead of Peter Criss, listeners heard Eric Carr sing “Beth,” a switch that still sets this greatest hits album apart.
That choice stands out considering the band changed the singer on a song closely tied to its original drummer.
How Eric Carr Took Over “Beth” on Kiss’ Greatest Hits Album
By then, Carr had held the drum seat since replacing Criss in 1980. However, “Beth” gave him his first lead vocal on a Kiss album.
Rather than build a new backing track, Kiss kept the original music and added Carr’s voice. According to KissFAQ’s account , the band even returned to the same studio where Criss recorded his version.
Still, Carr knew the song carried personal weight. KissFAQ quotes him telling KISS Crazy magazine, “At first I was real nervous about what the reaction would be (after all, it’s Peter’s song).”
Meanwhile, Criss told Kerrang!…