Menu

I Tested 8 Stop-Loss Brackets on 32,485 A-Share Trades. The '1:2 Risk-Reward' Rule Needed 33% and Got 24%
📰

I Tested 8 Stop-Loss Brackets on 32,485 A-Share Trades. The '1:2 Risk-Reward' Rule Needed 33% and Got 24%

DEV Community: python·Felixwang007·about 12 hours ago
#3BNltz1Q
#devtopython#devto#dev#stop#mean
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

Every trading book hands you the same rule: risk 1 to make 2. Set the stop at -5%, the target at +10%, and you only need to be right one time in three.

I had 32,485 A-share trades lying around, so I measured it. The rule got nowhere near one time in three. It hit 23.8% and only came out flat because of a bucket almost nobody budgets for.

The setup

587 A-share names (538 Shanghai main board, 29 STAR, 6 ChiNext), 321 daily bars each, 2025-07-17 to 2026-11-12.

Entry at the next day's open after a signal day. No same-bar fill, no lookahead.

Barriers measured from the entry price against intraday high/low , horizon 20 trading days, sampled every 5 days. Because that overlaps, I re-ran everything at step 20 (8,131 non-overlapping entries) and flag any result that changes sign.

When both barriers are touched on the same day I count it in its own bucket instead of silently picking a winner. Depending on width that bucket is 0.0%-1.7% of trades.

Filling at the barrier is optimistic.…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.