The Supreme Court has allowed the Income Tax Department to reopen assessments of Chetan and Nitin Sabharwal, sons of former Chief Justice of India YK Sabharwal, over shares sold for Rs 255 crore and subsequent property purchase in Delhi’s Sikandra Road.
A bench comprising Justices J B Pardiwala and K Vinod Chandran on October 28 upheld the 2015 notices that reopened the brothers’ earlier assessments. The court held that the notices were based on “tangible material”, citing the I-T Department ’s investigative unit report.
It said that the alleged overvaluation of shares and the use of proceeds to acquire another asset could involve “a diversion of income, accessable to tax under the guise of sale proceeds.” Here is what the case is about, and what the law says on reopening taxpayers’ assessments.
What were the transactions in question?
In 2007, the brothers and two other shareholders signed share purchase agreements with GYS Real Estate Pvt Ltd, wherein they agreed to sell their shares in Pawan Impex and…