Menu

I let AI draft my newsletter for a month — opens held, replies fell. Has anyone else seen this?

Reading 0:00
15s threshold

I've let AI draft my weekly newsletter for the last month, based on my past issues. Opens are basically flat — 38% before, 36–38% now — but replies fell from 8–12 per send to 1–2. Unsubscribes didn't move. The drafts read clean, but they lost the specific details I used to include: no named customer story, no "here's what I tried Tuesday" kind of line. Has anyone else had replies fall once AI took the first draft? Did you fix it by editing harder, going back to a human outline with AI filling it in, or dropping AI drafts entirely? What actually brought replies back?

submitted by /u/TheEmailGrowthLab
[link] [comments]