I have gone around and around, looked at all the pictures, read all the reviews, and I'm still torn, so I'm asking this venerable collection of watch nerds to make the case... basically "sell me this watch."

To fill the slot in my collection that gets the most wrist time, probably 60-65%.

(NOTE 1: I know someone will say, "Just go try them all and see what feels best." I don't live close to dealers of these brands, so I can't try them on in person.)

(NOTE 2: I know someone will say, "Just save a bit more and get X." I have many other, more important, financial responsibilities so my budget, around $1500 preowned, is self-imposed and not flexible.)

- Sinn 556i RS- I owned the plain 556i for two years before. Loved it! That - to me - is the platonic ideal, essential everyday wear. Sterile, stark, charming in its minimalism... but it is very minimal...…