Hi,
Planning Patagonia in November (W Trek + El Chaltén), ~10–12 nights camping, including exposed sites (Laguna Torre / Laguna de los Tres).
Looking for a 2P shelter in the 1–2 kg range that can handle:
sustained strong winds (gusts ~80–100 km/h)
heavy rain, possible light snow
above-tree-line exposure
Context:
2 people, shared load
pack weight ~15–18 kg/person
rocky ground → staking may be limited
trekking poles available
priority: wind stability > weight
Considering:
MSR Access 2 (~1.8 kg)
MSR Hubba Hubba (~1.7 kg)
Durston X-Mid 2 Solid (~1.1 kg)
Durston X-Dome 2 Solid (~1.4–1.5 kg est)
Questions:
Which of these has the best structural integrity in high wind (realistically)?
How reliable are trekking pole shelters when staking is compromised?
Is semi-freestanding (Access 2) a safer middle ground?
Any sub-2 kg shelters you’d trust more in these conditions (Slingfin, Scarp, etc.)?
Not looking to go stupid light if it compromises structural integrity in wind.
Looking for real-world…