In this excerpt from our print article “The $60,000 Unicorn Rye” in the Men’s Journal Fall 2026 Whiskey Special print edition, Wayne Curtis shares the history of the most sought-after American rye. Read the full story here .
A few months ago, a customer walked into LeNell’s Beverage Boutique , a liquor store just off a busy interstate highway in Birmingham, AL. Inside was a well-curated selection of whiskey and a clawfoot tub in which bottles of gin had been arrayed. But what really caught the man’s attention was a single empty whiskey bottle sitting on a shelf. “How did you get a Red Hook Rye?” he demanded, incredulous of the woman tending the shop.
For the uninitiated, Red Hook Rye is among the most sought-after American whiskeys—a true unicorn.…