A woman has won a nearly 19-year-old property dispute after the Telangana High Court set aside an eviction order passed against her over alleged unpaid rent and maintenance of Rs 56,000. The court held that a landlord must first prove the existence of a tenancy and cannot simply rely on a visual comparison of disputed signatures to prove it.
Justice Vakiti Ramakrishna Reddy was hearing S Shashi Rekha’s civil revision petition against a June 13, 2017 judgment of the Chief Judge of the City Small Causes Court, Hyderabad . The appellate court had reversed the Rent Controller’s dismissal of an eviction petition filed by Kothapalli Madhusudhan Rao.
“Denial of the tenancy or of the title of the landlord is not the same as wilful default in payment of rent… The burden of proving the due execution of a disputed document lies on the party relying on it,” the court said on November 3.…