I am kind of thinking of maybe a 12th gen i7/i9 Optiplex and slapping a quad port Intel NIC in it.
Does this sound good? Will ESXi complain about anything here? I tried it once on a 10th gen i7 Optiplex and it seemed happy, but I need something a little beefier than that. The one thing that concerns me is the newer Intel desktop chips and e-cores. I'm not sure how well ESXi will handle these, or if it knows how to properly handle scheduling with them.
Any better suggestions? I also wonder how much I can drop the power load by just removing the second CPU, but I suspect it will still use considerably more than something like an Optiplex.
I'll miss having 512 GB RAM, a boat load of cores, and redundant everything, but I need to be more practical. The rack server is just so expensive to run.
EDIT for specs -- It's an R740 with:
2x Xeon Gold 6148 @ 2.4 GHz (so 40 cores total)
512 GB RAM
8x 4 TB SATA SSDs in RAID10