In a Tow Center for Digital Journalism test at Columbia University, eight AI search tools were given 1,600 quotes from news articles and asked to name the source. They got it wrong more than 60% of the time. Perplexity had the lowest failure rate, at 37%, while Grok 3 got 94% wrong and often linked to pages that did not exist.
That result does not make AI search useless for research. It means the tool you pick should make checking easy: every claim linked to a source, ideally the exact passage, and for academic work, a paper you can open and cite. Some AI search engines are built around that. Others still treat sources as a footnote.
Four things that make an AI answer checkable
Every tool here was compared on the same four points.…