A tear underneath the arm of a man’s jacket within 46 minutes of its first use has led to a legal dispute, with the Chandigarh Consumer Commission directing the store to pay Rs 31,000 to the complainant. Rejecting the store’s claim that the damage occurred due to external use, and not a manufacturing defect, the commission noted the absence of an independent inspection report or expert opinion.
President Amrinder Singh Sidhu and member Brij Mohan Shama observed that the mere recording of an internal opinion that the damage was attributable to the complainant cannot be treated as conclusive proof, particularly when the store has neither established the basis of such assessment nor produced any expert evidence in support thereof.
In its November 4 order, the commission said, “The tear in question is stated to be located underneath the arm, at a relatively inconspicuous portion of the jacket.…