Every time you, a reader, posts a comment, it gives me a chance to reflect on the recipe. When the comment is positive, I'm proud and happy; my kid just scored the winning goal!
When a recipe gets a not-so-good comment, I'm bummed. Bad report card. Thankfully, most of our reviewed recipes get four or five stars. And some get LOTS of four- and five-star reviews. These are our straight-A students; our all-stars. The recipes you want to bookmark for the math team's next bake sale.
So now, without further ado, meet our Cookie All-Stars – the eight top-ranking cookie recipes on our site.
Photography and food styling by Liz Neily
A classic for a reason.
1) Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies
The winner and still champion: our guaranteed Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies. "I didn't think any recipe could be better than the original Toll House recipe, but this is," says reviewer Annerip. Our secret?…