John Wayne almost missed his first movie with Marlene Dietrich. Eighty-six years ago today, the future Western legend appeared opposite one of Hollywood’s biggest stars in Seven Sinners , but producer Joe Pasternak initially wanted another actor for the role.

Released October 25, 1940, the romantic drama paired Wayne with Dietrich after Pasternak abandoned plans to cast Franchot Tone. According to the American Film Institute , the producer changed direction after discovering Wayne was available. The unexpected pairing would lead to two more films together.

Next: John Wayne’s 1949 Western Took an Unexpected Risk That Helped Make It One of the Greatest Westerns

The Casting Change That Brought Two Stars Together

Wayne had already achieved a major breakthrough with John Ford’s Stagecoach in 1939.…