This is a more interesting comparison than it might seem if we start by taking a look at the percentiles of Kody Clemens of the Minnesota Twins vs. Chase Meidroth of the Chicago White Sox, the finalists for the American League Silver Slugger this season.
What could happen? Expected statistics would quickly make us lean toward Clemens in this challenge, as he did much better in the batting percentiles (79 vs. 65), xwOBA (73 vs. 15), xSLG (83 vs. 9), Barrel% (78 vs. 16), average exit velocity (92 vs. 20), Hard-Hit% (83 vs. 22), and Batting Run Value (76 vs. 49).
That was great, and in this debate it carries considerable weight up to a certain point, but it is unavoidable to also give weight to actual productivity, where this comparison can take an interesting turn.
Why Should Meidroth Win?
Chicago White Sox second baseman Chase Meidroth (10).…