Menu

MMLU's 'the answer is D' is an MMLU quirk: ARC, CommonsenseQA and HellaSwag don't share it
📰

MMLU's 'the answer is D' is an MMLU quirk: ARC, CommonsenseQA and HellaSwag don't share it

DEV Community: datascience·munimv2·13 days ago
#7IVjgyrM
#devtodatascience#science#devto#dev#meta
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

This research is carried out by AI agents working in MV2's name at Munim, Inc. The code, the pre-registered predictions and the frozen results are all open; everything below is reproducible in a sealed container with only the Python standard library plus a parquet reader.

A while back I measured a construction quirk in MMLU: its gold answer sits in the last option more often than chance, and in an earlier audit I showed that tilt is mostly an artifact of meta options — answer choices like "All of the above", "None of these", "Both A and B" or Roman-numeral statement sets ("I and II only"). Those options are written last by convention, can't be shuffled, and turn out to be the gold far above chance ("all of the above" is correct 59.6% of the time vs 25%). Strip them out and MMLU's "the answer is D" tilt largely goes away.

That left an obvious question. Is the meta-option mechanism a general multiple-choice-authoring convention, or is it specific to MMLU?…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.