The public reply under a 1-star review is read by the next ten shoppers, not by the person who already left. I use a three-line structure and five prompts so the answer stays calm, specific, and inside my refund policy.
The 3-line structure
Thank + name the specific problem. "Thanks for telling us the mug arrived chipped β that's on our packaging."
One concrete fix you can actually deliver. Replacement, partial refund β only what your policy allows.
Move it private. "Message us your order number and we'll sort it today."
Prompt 1 β the calm public reply
Here is a 1-star review: [REVIEW]. Facts: [WHAT HAPPENED, MY POLICY]. Write a public reply under 80 words: thank them, acknowledge the specific issue, state one fix I allow, invite them to message us. No excuses, don't blame the customer, never promise anything not in my policy.
The last sentence matters most. Without it, models invent refunds you never offered.
Prompt 2 β the unfair review
This review is inaccurate: [REVIEW]. True facts: [FACTS].β¦