Menu

Reading 0:00
15s threshold
Help with an ornament

from BWV 1053

Does anyone know how to play this ornament? In recordings it just sounds like "F#-G#-A" in a 32nd-32nd-dotted 8th rhythm. Like this:

https://preview.redd.it/oy0jd6b0ojzh1.png?width=737&format=png&auto=webp&s=cdd9ee0e99faa86089ef966621c8cc2da77da853

I also hear it played this way:

https://preview.redd.it/sm7xk3bxnjzh1.png?width=592&format=png&auto=webp&s=12df1ed56f58d1ebea62b75f335e17ff617fcec1

My best guess could be this:

Example 1

But I'm not really sure. Maybe the ornament should only start on the third note instead like most ornaments are in the baroque period like this.

Example 2

Or maybe even like this??

Example 3

Maybe this?

Example 4

submitted by /u/diamondminer1578
[link] [comments]