Obviously Smith was known more for his defense, but this was a truly anomalous award winner to me. This was actually his best offensive season by a lot of metrics (career highs .303 BA, .393 OBP, 40 doubles) and there was a gaping black hole at shortstop in the NL just before Barry Larkin made this his award for the next decade so it's hard to even say that it is undeserved.
Meanwhile, Bob Forch won the Silver Slugger for pitchers while slashing .298/.333/.509 with 2 HR. Just a funny comparison.