How hard is a puzzle level? Tile counts are a poor answer. A 144-tile layout can be gentler than a 100-tile one if the shape is forgiving. When I added 12 layouts to Instant Mahjong Solitaire, I wanted a number that tells players and me something real.
This post is about one cheap trick: measuring difficulty with random play.
The layouts
The game has 12 layouts, from 60 to 144 tiles: Harmony, Garden, Phoenix, Pyramid, Pagoda, Crane, Lotus, Butterfly, Dragon, Turtle, Bridge and Mountain. They differ in height, symmetry and how many tiles start locked under others.
Every deal is generated so that a winning path exists. That removes "impossible" from the equation, which leaves a different question: how easy is it to find the path?
The random-play bot
The measuring tool is almost embarrassingly simple.
// simplified sketch function randomPlay ( board , rng ) { while ( true ) { const moves = freePairs ( board ) ; if ( moves . length === 0 ) return board . isEmpty ( ) ; // cleared or stuck board .…