β Human-authored analysis; AI used for formatting and proofreading.
A team writes requirements for a healthcare app on AWS.
PHI data must never be anonymously readable.
The website must serve static assets to the public.
Both live in the same S3 bucket.
Encryption at rest is mandatory.
CloudTrail data events are required for the PHI bucket.
A scanner can check each of these against the live configuration. That's table stakes. The harder question is: can all five hold simultaneously on the same bucket? Once you ask it out loud, you can hear the contradiction. Requirements 1 + 2 + 3 cannot coexist. There is no S3 configuration where the same bucket is both anonymously readable and not-anonymously-readable.β¦