Jim Carrey is indisputably one of the most popular and successful comedic actors of his generation—but that doesn’t necessarily mean that his uniquely slapstick brand of comedy works for everybody.

The actor has produced some of the most iconic comedies of the ’90s, from Liar Liar to The Mask , but there are also a handful of movies in his filmography that struggle to walk the line between charmingly silly and unwaveringly senseless. For many, Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls falls in the latter category.

Released on this day in 1995, Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls is the immediate sequel to Carrey’s popular comedy from the previous year, which helped thrust the actor even further into the public spotlight.…