Nine years after a 24-year-old resident doctor died at Surat’s New Civil Hospital, the Gujarat High Court has quashed an FIR against two senior doctors accused of abetting his suicide, holding that the investigation material did not establish the essential ingredients of the offence under Section 306 of the IPC.
Observing that “routine departmental instructions, academic reprimands, or allocation of ward work during an initial orientation period cannot be legally elevated to the status of ‘instigation’ under Section 107 IPC”, the court added that “the inability to cope with a demanding residency programme is deeply tragic”, but the evidence did not establish a deliberate criminal design by the doctors.
Justice P M Raval of the Gujarat HC, in a judgment pronounced on October 29, quashed the 2017 FIR registered at Khatodara police station in Surat and the consequential proceedings, including a case pending before the Additional District Judge, Surat, against the two petitioners.
The court held that the…