I’m curious to hear about the specific interpretative choices that drive you crazy—the kind that feel like they ignore the score or the structural logic of a piece. I’ll start with three that always get to me, and the recordings are all timestamped for your convenience
1. Prokofiev, Piano Sonata No. 7 (III. Precipitato)
When pianists treat this like a speed competition, the percussive weight and "machinery" of the rhythm completely vanish.
The Mark: Sokolov – He maintains the grit and rhythmic clarity.
The Miss: Buniatishvili – The tempo obscures the intentional "heaviness" of the writing.
Syncopations are important
2. Schubert, Sonata in G Major, D.894 (III. Menuetto)
The unwritten "sentimental" slow-down for the Trio. It breaks the pulse and makes the movement feel disjointed.
The Mark: Richter – Seamless and structurally sound.
The Miss: Brendel – The gear shift feels indulgent rather than musical.
No sentimentality allowed here!
3. Brahms, Symphony No. 4 (IV.…