A post about changing engineering interviews pulled 155 comments on Hacker News this week. On DEV this month, "We're Building AI to Replace Ourselves" passed 200. Everyone's arguing about the same thing from different angles, so let me ask it directly.
Would you hire a junior developer who's productive with AI, but stuck without it?
I keep going back and forth.
The case for yes:
Nobody hires a developer to work without Google, Stack Overflow or an IDE. AI is the tool now, so why test without it?
A junior who ships working features with AI on day one is more useful than one who can reverse a linked list on a whiteboard.
Seniors use AI all day too. Holding juniors to a different standard feels a bit unfair.
The case for no:
AI is confidently wrong sometimes. If you can't read the code it writes, you can't catch that.
Debugging production at 2 a.m. is where the real learning happens, and it's hard to learn by pasting errors into a chat.
Someone has to review what the AI produces.…