When two men in the custody of the West Bengal police were killed this week within 24 hours of each other, the accounts of the deaths were identical: Each accused was taken to the crime scene for a “reconstruction”, where he snatched a service revolver and fired, and was then killed in retaliatory fire. Prahlad Das, 23, accused of raping and murdering a 17-year-old in Gaighata, was taken out near midnight; Samaul Sheikh, 40, an undertrial in the murder of a BJP worker, was taken by the CID to Dhulian that afternoon; and at Baruipur in July, Prabhas Mondal had died in the same fashion.
The repetition is the form the encounter now takes as a technique of governance. This mirrors Michael Taussig’s public secret: A story nobody is asked to believe and everybody is asked to accept.…