The Karnataka High Court recently upheld a single-judge order dismissing a petition filed by a 25-year-old Indian Army aspirant seeking the constitution of a Review Medical Board (RMB) to re-examine him after he was declared medically unfit due to his kidney size, despite securing the 51st rank on the merit list.
A division bench of Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice K S Hemalekha, in its order dated October 29, said, “This court cannot review the competent authority’s decision on the merits in proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The competent authority’s decision cannot be faulted on the grounds of arbitrariness.”
Monish N Aradhya applied to join the Indian Army earlier this year. Following the written examination, he underwent a medical examination before the Special Medical Board (SNB), which declared him unfit due to a small left kidney and other medical grounds.
Aradhya later appealed to the Appellate Medical Board (AMB).…