Hand up, I thought the hiring of Luke Fickell four years ago was indeed a home run hire.
He was the hottest candidate a program like Wisconsin football could land; landing Fick felt like the Badgers landed a program-defining coach who would bring Wisconsin back to relevance and into the College Football Playoff.
The Fickell Era in Madison got off to an exciting start. The Badgers had massive turnover on a roster that floundered under Paul Chryst at the end of his tenure. They landed big-name transfer portal targets like quarterback Tanner Mordecai and other players who were once highly-rated prospects coming out of high school, while also retaining their star running back, Braelon Allen.
The staff was recruiting well at a national level. There was excitement. There was hype. Things were getting exciting. They were doing everything right.
Unfortunately, the product on the field never met the heightened expectations. In the first three seasons under Fickell the Badgers finished 7-6, 5-7, and 4-8.…