Menu

CMV: Vichy France was a legitimate continuation of the French state during WW2, not the Free France movement

Reddit r/changemyview·u/Wayoutofthewayof·7 months ago
#CVL1xMMN
#government#gaulle#france#legitimate#french
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

I think that a lot of heavy lifting for legitimization of the Free French was done by the Brits mostly due to strategic reasons, not for their actual belief that De Gaulle's government held legitimacy. I think the convincing evidence is:

Petain was a legitimate PM appointed through constitutional provision that had full legal rights to sign the armistice with the Germans under the law of the French republic. In that sense him being charged for that by De Gaulle's government was ridiculous.

De Gaulle had no political mandate to lead France and he had no political succession to inherit such a position.

Vast majority of French generals recognized the authority of the Vichy government, including those in overseas territories that had no coercion from Germany to do so.…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.