This is for when you're ordering anyway.
I went through the menus of 13 independent pizza shops in Pennsylvania that sell both a 12 inch and an 18 inch plain pie. All off Slice, so online prices, in store could be different.
The middle price for two 12s was $24. For one 18 it was $19.75. The 18 was cheaper at all 13.
Also it's bigger. An 18 is about 254 square inches. Two 12s together are about 226. So about $4 less for about 12% more pizza.
You can check your own place in ten seconds. An 18 is 2.25 times a 12. So if the 18 costs less than 2.25 times the 12 price, it wins.
No chains. I didn't count coupons, a 2 for 1 would flip it.
Where else does this happen? I'm guessing there's stuff where the bigger size is the worse deal and I'd like to know which.