T he first rule of Fight Club (1999) is that its fans talk about it constantly. They talk in public places, extolling the film’s edgy virtues to anyone within earshot, and they talk on online forums with the blinds tightly shut . Possibly, they talk about it more today – with more passion and excitement – than they did when the movie was released more than a quarter of a century ago. One can’t help but wonder whether this is a good thing or not.

Still, if you can’t beat them, join them – let’s say a few words about David Fincher ’s Fight Club . It's a film that lends itself to different readings. It tests and teases the viewer much as its anti-hero, Tyler Durden, tests its unnamed sad-sack hero. Ed Norton plays the white-collar wage-slave who measures his sorry existence with a range of IKEA home furnishings. Brad Pitt co-stars as his galvanising agent of irreversible change, a soap salesman and red-pill revolutionary who preaches a gospel of liberative primal urges.…