Courtesy of the Pebble Hunting newsletter:
Why don’t the Dodgers, who have every advantage, just build a 130-win team?
If they did, they’d be about 80 percent likely to win the World Series. (Before the 2019 NBA playoffs, the Warriors were, according to oddsmakers, about 70 percent likely to win it all.) As it is—with the Dodgers maybe five or 10 wins better than their average playoff opponent²—they’re around 20 percent entering each postseason.
A 130-win team is pretty close to the theoretical maximum. If one team had managed to acquire the best player at every position this year, along with the five best starting pitchers this year—according to Baseball Prospectus’ WARP, those were Gabriel Moreno, Pete Alonso, Brice Turang, Kevin McGonigle, Miguel Vargas, James Wood, Pete Crow-Armstrong, Fernando Tatís Jr., and Yordan Alvarez; and Cristopher Sánchez, Jacob Misiorowski, Cam Schlittler, Jesús Luzardo and Gavin Williams—they would have gotten 81 WARP from their 14 primary players.…