β Human-authored analysis; AI used for formatting and proofreading.
You run a security scanner on your AWS environment. It finds 47 issues. The leaders hear: "our infrastructure has 47 things wrong with it." This is the problem with bug-finding tools. Every finding is bad news.
What Amazon learned from a bank
A finance company could not understand their own IAM policies. The policies were too complex to reason about manually.
Amazon team said: "We're formalizing the semantics of the policy language. We can prove what your policies allow and don't allow. Mathematically."
The bank increased their workload and their spending. Because AWS proved properties.
The asymmetry
There are two different things a security tool can tell you:
Bug finding: "We found 47 issues in your environment."
The scanners CSPM, CNAPP, Prowler, Scout Suite do it. They check your configuration against a list of known-bad patterns. Each finding is a problem. The report is a list of problems. More findings = more problems.β¦