Menu

should I reopen negotiations after HR basically closed the conversation?

Reddit r/negotiation·u/butterfly97_·7 months ago
#DzMwGyRG
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

I’m in a bit of a tricky spot and would appreciate objective input.

I’m currently in an investment role. I have an expected merit increase (~6–7%) effective soon and a promotion likely later this year (~10–15%). My current setup is stable with strong benefits (30 days leave, training/education support, etc.).

I received an external offer:

Senior Manager title

Initially ~15% increase → negotiated to ~25%

Smaller / less stable platform

I told them my expectation was ~35–40% given:

I’m leaving a stable environment

I’m giving up upcoming increases

I’m taking on more risk

HR said:

25% is already a stretch

Going above ~30% is very difficult due to internal parity

In the last call, I reiterated my range (35–40%) and he basically ended the conversation with “good luck” (which felt like a polite close due to misalignment, not sure if it was a close or testing me?)

Now after thinking it through, I feel I might be open to something like ~30–32%, but I didn’t communicate that at the time.

My plan was to…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.