One simple question. No simple answer. Featuring Ben Gibbard, Lou Barlow, Mitski, Kill Rock Stars, Matador, Sub Pop, Anthony Fantano, Michael Azerrad, Ryan Schreiber, and many more
Our list of the 100 Best Indie Rock Albums of All Time offers Pitchfork’s definition of the genre of indie rock. But the borders of indie rock have been contested since the first person went through the “indie” bin at a record store and pulled out a record by major-label artists the Velvet Underground.
I reached out to 33 people whose art and work have shaped the borders of this genre. There is not one thing we can agree on when it comes to defining indie rock. Some people freely interchange “indie” and “indie rock.” You’d think that “indie rock exists” would be unanimous, but there are those who believe that indie rock does not, in fact, exist. “Indie is a descriptor of the band and not the band’s music or an actual genre,” reads a classic Pitchfork style guide. Well, we’ll see about that.…