For context, I'm talking about Virginia's Assault Weapon Ban's justification, more can be found here .
The above text states that ar-15s are just machine guns, just in semi-automatic form to start. Its summary of argument says AR-15s "are machineguns, except that they—at least to start—have semiautomatic fire rather than automatic fire," and later calls the machine gun the AR-15's "fraternal twin."
This absolutely makes no sense whatsoever, since that one distinction is the literal definition of what a "machine gun" is. By definition: federal law defines a machine gun as a weapon that fires more than one shot "by a single function of the trigger." That is the entire test. Saying "an AR-15 is a machine gun except it isn't automatic" is like saying "a bicycle is a motorcycle except it has no motor." You've just removed the thing that defines the category.
The brief argues auto sears, forced-reset triggers, and similar parts make AR-15s machine guns in practice.…