Consider a proposed page after PDF parsing and field extraction: a customer document is queued for external sharing, but its release record cannot establish which redacted artifact was approved for signing. The on-call sees an artifact identifier, an approval identifier, and a failed release check. That's a useful alert. A dashboard saying extraction succeeded would tell the responder almost nothing about whether personal data survived.
Short answer: use rules for fields that must be exact, model extraction for prose and unfamiliar layouts, and validation before either result can authorize redaction. For an e-commerce team sharing customer documents, the deciding evidence is the relationship between the inspected redacted artifact, its signature, and its audit trail. Neither a parse success nor a schema-valid model response establishes that relationship.
The rule-based PDF parsing versus model-based field extraction question is therefore about accuracy, fidelity, and operating cost at a release boundary.…