In this excerpt from our print article “Eggnog, Evolved” in the Men’s Journal Fall 2026 Whiskey Special print edition, Jeffrey Morgenthaler shares his recipe for the ideal holiday ‘nog. Read the full story .
I have a confession to make: I love eggnog.
I know what you’re thinking, but hear me out. I’m not glugging the artificial stuff in the carton you find in grocery stores. During the holidays, I always have a hankering for the real thing—made from scratch with honest ingredients and well-crafted spirits.
Related: These Four Tips Will Elevate Your Holiday Cocktails
People have been drinking eggnog-like concoctions since at least the 13th century, when medieval monks were mixing milk with ale or wine, eggs, and figs in a hot drink called “posset.” By the 17th century, aristocratic Europeans splurged with a more refined version of the beverage made with brandy and sherry.…