My wife and I are both teachers want to supplement our California State Teacher Retirement pension and Roth IRAs with some Roth 403(b) funds. We work for different districts but have some overlap on the well-rated choices of vendors as seen at https://403bwise.org/advocacy/rating\_system .
My choices: CalSTRS Pension2 (Green), Vanguard (Green - )
Wife's choices: Fidelity (Green + ), CalSTRS Pension2 (Green), Vanguard (Green - )
CalSTRS Pension2 offers Vanguard funds, so choosing that or Vanguard could get us VOO/VTI-type equivalents. Fidelity also has similar index funds that match what we want from a Vanguard fund.
The Keep It Simple part of me wants to choose the CalSTRS or Vanguard option for both of us, as that would minimize having multiple brokerage firms to deal with. But, if Fidelity is rated "+" and Vanguard is "-". (Our primary investments are all at Schwab.)
If I can get more or less the same index funds we want at any of the 3 choices, is there a clear choice here?…