Menu

Errors in the research of Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman - Marginal REVOLUTION

Reading 0:00
15s threshold

AI issues its judgment :

138 papers audited

2,035 problems found

147 serious enough to change a headline number

69% of papers have at least one

97% of major and moderate errors with a clear direction overstate the paper’s claim

And on the method:

Two independent audits of each paper. One by Claude Opus 5.5, one by OpenAI’s GPT-6 Astra, neither seeing the other’s work. Each obtained the paper, its appendices and its replication data, recomputed the headline numbers from the authors’ own files and, where possible, from the original sources (tax statistics, national accounts, Federal Reserve and survey data), checked that cited sources say what is claimed, and probed every assumption the conclusions rest on.

Then an adjudicator.…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.