Illustration by Charlotte Trounce
“Is Your Cat Confused by the Referendum?” This viral video, rather than any actual campaign material, is my prevailing memory of the 2011 vote on whether Britain should change its electoral system. In it, the debate between first past the post (FPTP) and the alternative vote (AV) system is explained – with graphs! – via the medium of cats. In its illustrative example ballot, there is a clear majority (61 per cent to 39 per cent) for a cat to win over a dog, yet when three cat candidates (Moderate Cat, Casual Cat and Distracted Cat) stand against one dog under FPTP, the vote is split between them. Shock horror! The dog wins. But under AV, the votes of the least popular cats in each counting round are reallocated to second-choice candidates, until it’s one cat vs one dog.…