Is there a bathroom leak or not?
That seemingly simple, and years-unanswered, question has exploded into a vicious legal battle between Guillermina Girardi and her upper Manhattan co-op complex, Castle Village , which wants to redo her shower to repair an alleged leak into the bathroom below — all at her expense. On top of that: the complex wants Girardi to cough up roughly $200,000 in legal fees over the ongoing dispute.
As for whether there’s actually a leak? The building management claims there is. Ten city inspectors say there isn’t. As for the downstairs neighbor — well, it’s complicated.
Castle Village resident Guillermina Girardi maintains her shower pan is not leaking into the unit below — but her co-op says otherwise. Tamara Beckwith/NY Post
The question over the alleged leak, and its alleged damage in the unit below, has raged on for three years. Court records
In the spring of 2023, six weeks after Girardi moved in, the downstairs neighbors reported “a small leak.…