SEOs were asking why is the favicon missing. Gary explained that the folks at VLC for some reason served the teapot - 418 status code and Google obviously treats it like it treats "most other 4xx errors: basically "not found," Gary wrote.
So why didn't Google drop it from the index? He wrote, "Because VLC is arguably one of the most important pages on the internet (thanks for all your hard work since... well, forever!), Search temporarily protected the URL from falling out of the index right away." I mean, it also can be because if you specifically search for the site, Google may also show it - another way of interpreting it being an important page?