Nvidia closed at 162.85 on Friday. On Oct 6 it was 239.24. That is -31.9%.
Every time a big name drops like this, half the comments say "buy the dip" and the other half say "falling knife". I wanted numbers.
The test:
- 500 most traded US stocks, Oct 2017 – Aug 2026, delisted ones included
- Signal: a stock fell 15% or more in 10 trading days while the broad market was calm (equal-weight index above its 200-day average and not down more than 2% over those 10 days)
- Buy at the next open, sell at the close 20 trading days later, 0.10% costs
- Compared with a random day in the same stock, same year, same calm-market condition
Result, 2,943 cases:
- Average after 20 days: -0.29%. Median: -1.33%. 45.8% of cases ended in plus.
- A random day in the same stock: +0.90% on average.
- The gap is -1.19 points, with a 95% range from -3.41 to +1.18. So the honest reading is "no edge", not "proven worse".
- Against a random other stock on the same day the gap is -0.64 points (range -2.19 to +1.06).…