Menu

Can a research review leave a checkable record? Help me break this.
📰

Can a research review leave a checkable record? Help me break this.

DEV Community: opensource·GnomeMan4201·16 days ago
#N1iDQj9u
#devtoopensource#devto#dev#review#reviewer
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

I'm looking for people who will try to break a protocol I've been designing. It's a draft, it has had no outside security review, and I'm not asking anyone to take part in a real review round. I want the design attacked before I put real research through it.

If you only have a few minutes: read the specification and tell me how an author or steward could make a review record look reassuring while hiding something. A concrete counterexample is worth more than general feedback.

The problem

I do independent security and LLM research. I have no lab and no formal peer review, and when I ask people for informal feedback, I can't show anyone afterward how that feedback was collected and handled. Things that can go wrong even when everyone is honest:

Exposure. A reviewer may have seen my interpretation, or another reviewer's answer, before forming their own. A signature can't show that didn't happen.

Editing or omission.…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.