200,000 Catan deals in three seconds: the 68.9% stat that hides a caveat
A number I published on our board generator site kept getting quoted without its second half: 68.9% of random Catan token layouts put a 6 next to an 8. That is true for a freely shuffled pile. It does not apply to the lettered setup in the rulebook. The gap between those two claims is the interesting part, so here is the simulation, the code, and where the number stops being useful.
The question, stated precisely
Catan's base board has 19 hexes: one desert and 18 number tokens. The tokens are a multiset, one each of 2 and 12, two each of 3 through 6 and 8 through 11. A 6 and an 8 each appear on 5 of 36 dice combinations, so an intersection touching both collects on 10 of 36 rolls before any other hex is counted.
The question: if you deal those 18 tokens at random onto the board, how often does at least one pair of neighbouring hexes carry a 6 and an 8?
Two details decide the answer.…