WebAuthn backup state: what passkey synchronisation does to assurance
Passkeys make authentication easier because users can sign in without a password and, on many platforms, reuse a credential across devices. That convenience changes the evidence available to a relying party. A credential that can be restored from a cloud account is not equivalent to a single hardware key that never leaves one device. WebAuthn exposes signals that help an application reason about that difference, but the signals need careful interpretation.
The Web Authentication specification defines authenticator data fields that describe whether a credential is backup eligible and whether it is currently backed up. The terminology matters. Backup eligibility describes whether the credential can be backed up at all. Backup state describes whether the authenticator reports that it is currently backed up.…