TL;DR
The right Sonner alternative depends on what Sonner does not do for you, and if nothing is wrong, keep it: it is by far the most downloaded of the four toast libraries compared here and has a stack, swipe and promise toasts built in. Pick react-hot-toast for the smallest bundle (4.8 kB gzip) and a headless hook, or React-Toastify for progress bars, a queue limit and a notification history. Pick a source-owned toast, such as the free Wingo UI Toast, when you need to change how the stack behaves on phones, for screen readers or in your design system.
You go looking for a Sonner alternative when something about the toast stops fitting: the bundle, a design system that fights its stylesheet, an accessibility review, or action buttons that are hard to hit on a phone. Sonner is still the default React toast for good reasons, so leaving it should fix a specific problem.…