On development data our US score had a mean rank IC of +0.0085: very slightly right, on average. Yet the long-short portfolio built from it (top 10% against bottom 10%, rebalanced weekly, after costs) had a Sharpe ratio of −0.21. How can a ranking be right and the portfolio wrong?
1. IC uses everyone, the portfolio uses the tails
Rank IC measures the whole ranking, all ~100 stocks. The portfolio only owns the top and bottom 10. A score can order the middle of the pack slightly well and the extremes badly, and the portfolio only feels the extremes.
2. Averages hide size
IC treats each day equally. A portfolio's result is dominated by a few big days. Many small correct days can be wiped out by a handful of large wrong ones. In our sealed US year, three stocks (QCOM, DOW, TMO) accounted for 43% of the portfolio's result.
3. Costs
Weekly rebalancing means turnover, and every trade costs something. We charge 5 basis points per unit of turnover, and also report the result at double costs.…