Menu

Carson v. Makin, St. Mary Catholic Parish, NY Times Opinion Pieces, and Inconsistent Judicial Skepticism

Reddit r/supremecourt·u/gravygrowinggreen·10 days ago
#QCm2h74G
#colorado#evidence#intent#opinion#racial
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

I made the mistake of listening to Advisory Opinions again. I really shouldn't do that. Today's blood pressure spiking moment was in the second half of the podcast. Context:

In the oral arguments for St. Mary Catholic Parish, Justice Amy Coney Barret asked counsel for Colorado the following question:

But we do have, you know, this op-ed in the New York Times by Aaron Tang saying, hey, don't worry, there's this way that, after Carson, Maine and other states can achieve the same result, impose these nondiscrimination requirements because all these religions that hold these traditional beliefs will then be unable to participate in these programs. So I think, even if it's not what Colorado did here, don't we have to think about that in deciding this case and how it will affect other programs?

The New York Times opinion piece is here: (apologies for the weird source.…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.